Welcome to the Doctors' Portal
00:00 Sunday
Mediclinic News : TARIFF PROPOSALS ‘RISKY’, DOCTOR EMPLOYMENT RULES ‘OLD FASHIONED’ – BROOMBERG

Title

TARIFF PROPOSALS ‘RISKY’, DOCTOR EMPLOYMENT RULES ‘OLD FASHIONED’ – BROOMBERG

Date

2019-03-11

Link

https://medbriefafrica.co.za/tariff-proposals-risky-doctor-employment-rules-old-fashioned-broomberg/

News Description

MED BRIEF AFRICA The prospect of a bargaining chamber to settle tariff negotiation issues, as recommended in the Health Market Inquiry (HMI) report, is ‘risky’, Discovery Health CEO, Dr Jonny Broomberg, told Gynaecology Management Group (GMG)/SASOG Private Practice Weekend delegates on Saturday. He was, however, encouraged generally by the HMI supply-side regulator concept to facilitate structures for providers and funders to negotiate tariffs as well as allowing for certain negotiations to take place outside the structure: “This is something like we had before.” But the problem, Broomberg warned, will arise when there is no agreement and a maximum rate set by the proposed bargaining chamber will be enforced. This, he said, would have to be watched carefully as ‘we can’t control what’s going on in the bargaining chamber’ This, he said, was potentially very risky: “Someone like the minister comes in and rules, but if it works properly, gives a proper voice to the providers and funders and we don’t have politicians coming in calling the shots when there is deadlock, then it should be fine but still a real issue to keep our eyes on. “My view,” he added, “based on discussions I have had with officials in government, is that it needs a whole new bureaucracy. But being pragmatic I have to ask the question: when will it see the light of day? I don’t think it will see the light of day at least for the next few years – if ever. “If there is going to be a structure like this emerging, it will come out of collaboration in the private sector with funders and people like yourselves, management groups, going to the competition authorities and asking them to ‘give us permission to do this ourselves for the benefit of all stakeholders’. Only reason we can’t do it today is because of the Competition Commission.” Another HMI point raised by the Discovery CEO was its “strong views” on the Health Professions Council of SA (HPCSA) rules – rulings that doctors can’t work or bill in teams, and more specifically, can’t be employed by hospitals. “I know from the various discussions I have had on this is that there are divisions on the doctor employment issues. As far as I am concerned, it is a 200-year-old debate and therefore very out of date. Everywhere else in the world there are entities employing doctors. Doctors are even setting up organisations to employ themselves – doesn’t have to be a hospital that employs them. But here they are not even allowed to do that which to me is very old fashioned. “To run modern healthcare, people do have to work in teams. Employment is spreading out and if the terms are right employment is a very safe alternative. In the US, for example, 90% of graduates are seeking employment. “So we support the HMI on this and it will be interesting to see what comes of it.” On a related point, Broomberg noted that what was also missing in South Africa were corporate structures to support private practitioners. NHI – ‘high road to catastrophe!’ As expected, Broomberg spent some time on issues pertaining to developments and the current status of National Health Insurance (NHI), alluding specifically to the “public spat” between the Department of Health and Treasury on “where’s the money coming from?” and “what will happen to medical schemes under NHI”. On the latter, he indicated “that the small group in the presidency” advocating amendments to what was believed to be the final proposal – resulting in the Bill bouncing in and out of Cabinet – was most concerning. These changes, said Broomberg, represented a “high road to catastrophe” – changes which included preventing medical schemes from providing cover for conditions already covered by NHI. An example he gave was ante-natal care, delivery, and post-natal care, all covered by NHI: “so you can claim from a clinic in Dobsonville” but not if carried out privately in the northern suburbs of Johannesburg. In is SONA address, said Broomberg, President Cyril Ramaphosa announced that the NHI Bill would be “coming to Cabinet soon”: “What did he mean? We just hope that when it finally reaches parliament all that is in it is reasonable. If not, there will have to be a public effort to prevent it from destroying the private sector.”
Created at 2019/03/18 02:12 PM by Mediclinic
Last modified at 2019/03/18 02:12 PM by Mediclinic